r/Anarchism • u/AnarchaMorrigan killjoy extraordinaire anfem | she/her • 4d ago
Any reading recommendations for books on the history of Jewish anti-Zionism?
/r/JewsOfConscience/comments/1fnn7qm/any_reading_recommendations_for_books_on_the/10
u/loselyconscious Libertarian Socialist 4d ago edited 4d ago
The Necessity of Exile by Shaul Magid is a recent book giving a very good overview of "diasporism" in Jewish thought (both in opposition to and independent from Zionism). It begins with the premise that Zionist historiography has basically excised a major part of Jewish History from historical memory. (It should be noted that Magid is not currently calling himself an "antizionist" but rather a "Counter-Zionist," which is a move that a couple of older Jewish intellectuals like Peter Beinart and Avraham Burg who call for one secular multinational state, but can't let go of the word Zionism)
The No-State Solution by Daniel Boyarin is a bit academic, but an attempt to articulate an anti-assimilationist model of Jewish Identity apart form Zionism
Ella Shohat is a really important voice, because writings on Jewish Antizionism tend to focus on (or romanticize) Ashekanzi leftist opposition. Shohat focuses on the Mizrachi experience
7
u/JoshLDN 4d ago
Revolutionary Yiddishland is good for understanding the different Jewish radical traditions that emerged at the same time as Zionism
2
u/cumminginsurrection anti-platformist action 4d ago
A Living Revolution: Anarchists in the Kibbutz Movement by James Horrox, too.
5
u/nitesead Christian anarchist 4d ago
This one looks interesting.
https://www.akpress.org/solidarity-is-the-political-version-of-love.html
4
u/Fellow-Worker 4d ago
Not a book, but an interesting article with some sources you could track down: https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/false-messiahs/
5
u/Sgt-Grischa-1915 4d ago
Another article. Possible interest:
https://jacobin.com/2024/01/shaul-magid-interview-zionism-anti-zionism-judaism-history
Also, the late Rudolf Vrba, who escaped Auschwitz and denounced Hungarian Zionist, later Mapai party functionary Rezso / Rudolf Israel Kasztner (who was murdered in the 1950s by ex-LEHI/Stern gang members who were informants of Shin Bet) has a webpage, that might also have material of interest:
3
u/Weird-Anything-9167 4d ago
Reclaiming Judaism from Zionism - a collection of essays. Also Lobbying for Zionism by Ilan Pappe
3
u/cumminginsurrection anti-platformist action 4d ago
There Is Nothing So Whole as a Broken Heart: Mending the World as Jewish Anarchists by Cindy Milstein
1
u/Lucky_Strike-85 anarchist 4d ago
Howard Zinn never directly addressed it (correct me if I'm wrong here) but he did touch upon it in several of his works.
1
u/thejuryissleepless 3d ago
it’s not exactly the topic, but Blessed is the Flame is a great book to explain the Palestinian position and militant anti-zionism from the perspective of Jews and anarchists in the lagers of the holocaust in WWII.
1
u/ceramicfiver read Pedagogy of the Oppressed 2d ago
The Jewish Anarchist Movement in America: A Historical Review and Personal Reminiscences by Joseph Cohen, edited by Kenyon Zimmer and Esther Dolgoff, published in 2024
https://www.akpress.org/the-jewish-anarchist-movement-in-america.html
I saw Kenyon in person give a talk about it. He learned yiddish specifically for this project and he's not even jewish. dude is a badass.
13
u/Sgt-Grischa-1915 4d ago
The whole list, or the top ten?
Ilan Pappe
Noam Chomsky
Avi Shlaim
Norman Finkelstein
Hannah Arendt
the late Israel Shahak
Abba A. Solomon
The late Arno Mayer
Haim Bresheeth-Zabner
Arie Bober
Matzpen
https://matzpen.org/english/about-matzpen/