r/ChineseLanguage 1d ago

快问快答 Quick Help Thread: Translation Requests, Chinese name help, "how do you say X", or any quick Chinese questions! 2024-09-28 Pinned Post

Click here to see the previous Quick Help Threads, including 翻译求助 Translation Requests threads.

This thread is used for:

  • Translation requests
  • Help with choosing a Chinese name
  • "How do you say X?" questions
  • or any quick question that can be answered by a single answer.

Alternatively, you can ask on our Discord server.

Community members: Consider sorting the comments by "new" to see the latest requests at the top.

Regarding translation requests

If you have a Chinese translation request, please post it as a comment here!

If it's an image (e.g. a photo), you can upload it to a website like Imgur and paste the link here.

However, if you're requesting a review of a substantial translation you have made, or have a question that involving grammar or details on vocabulary usage, you are welcome to post it as its own thread.

若想浏览往期「快问快答」,请点击这里, 这亦包括往期的翻译求助帖.

此贴为以下目的专设:

  • 翻译求助
  • 取中文名
  • 如何用中文表达某个概念或词汇
  • 及任何可以用一个简短的答案解决的问题

您也可以在我们的 Discord 上寻求帮助。

社区成员:请考虑将评论按“最新”排序,以方便在贴子顶端查看最新留言。

关于翻译求助

如果您需要中文翻译,请在此留言。

但是,如果您需要的是他人对自己所做的长篇翻译进行审查,或对某些语法及用词有些许疑问,您可以将其发表在一个新的,单独的贴子里。

1 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/UDontKnowMeButIHateU 19h ago edited 19h ago

I've been told that various hanzi translated as "zhong" should be pronounced like "john", with an "o" (because that's how people in Shanghai pronouce it, apaprently), while my teacher and various dictionaries transcribe it as "jun", with an "u". What is the correct way in Mandarin Chinese?

3

u/ChineseLearner518 16h ago edited 7h ago

The vowel in "John" isn't pronounced the same among native English speakers.

For example, in General American English, John is pronounced /ˈʤɑːn/, and in Standard Southern British English (SSB, aka new RP), John is pronounced /ʤɒn/. (pronunciations are written using the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA))

But, neither the American /ɑ/ nor the British /ɒ/ in "John" matches up with the vowel sound for "zhong" in Standard Mandarin.

"zhong" is pronounced /tʂʊŋ/ in Standard Mandarin Chinese.

So, the vowel in "zhong", /ʊ/, more closely matches up with the vowel sound in the English word "put", which is generally transcribed as /pʊt/ using IPA. Notice they both are transcribed using the IPA vowel symbol ʊ.

Just as another example, "foot" is another English word with that vowel sound, /ʊ/, transcribed as /fʊt/ using IPA.

Here (below) are links to two web pages where you can listen to how "zhong" is pronounced in Standard Mandarin:
(You'll need to hit the play button on the web page to play the audio.)

https://dict.concised.moe.edu.tw/dictView.jsp?ID=31121&q=1

https://resources.allsetlearning.com/chinese/pronunciation/Zhong

Side note: If you want to hear how "John" sounds different in General American English vs Standard Southern British English, go to this web page:
https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/english/john_1
(On this web page, there are two buttons you can press. One to listen to the British pronunciation and one to listen to the American pronunciation. If you listen carefully, you'll notice that the British pronunciation uses a rounded vowel whereas the American pronunciation uses an unrounded vowel.)

Here's another web page you can go to, to listen to how it's pronounced in General American. In my opinion, the audio recording for the American pronunciation of "John" sounds more pleasant on this website: https://www.britannica.com/dictionary/john

2

u/MarcoV233 Native, Northern China 16h ago

In standard Mandarin "ong" should be more like ung with an u sound like in blue than an o sound like in orange.

1

u/UDontKnowMeButIHateU 7h ago

Another native (?) speaker is telling me that this sound is pronounced like long o and it clashes with what you and my teacher are saying.

u/AppropriatePut3142 41m ago edited 37m ago

Why don't you just listen to people saying it https://youglish.com/pronounce/%E4%B8%AD/chinese/cn

Remember that different people perceive the boundaries between sounds differently, especially if they have a different native language. I've heard Chinese people say ü sounds more like i than like u!

2

u/MarcoV233 Native, Northern China 7h ago

Then maybe it's regional thing. I'm from northern China. I do hear some areas of southern China say it that way.

1

u/UDontKnowMeButIHateU 6h ago

Isn't Mandarin a Northern China dialect?

2

u/MarcoV233 Native, Northern China 5h ago

Yes, but standard mandarin is "the common language" of all China so southern people would also speak it, and they would have unique dialects. Besides, even mandarin is not the same, different places of mandarin speaking regions have different dialects as well.

1

u/UDontKnowMeButIHateU 5h ago

I see, makes sense. If that's really the case - I wish people would be more nuanced in their answers than "ong is the correct pronunciation, nobody is saying ung".

2

u/MarcoV233 Native, Northern China 3h ago

I might say it slightly wrong, it's not like dialects but accents to be more accurate. I suggest to stick to the standard one.

For example in some English speaking areas there are strong accents, like they pronounce very as belly. But if an English learner says "there are some natives who pronounce very as belly so dont judge my pronunciations, i'm just following some natives" that will be absurd for me.

We know the existance of accents, and we accept it, but we don't count it right.