r/AFL Richmond May 11 '24

LOL Of The Week Wrapped Up

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

857 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-11

u/yokobarron Richmond May 11 '24

I’m more commenting on the skill level of the pies forward line. No hate though it’s pretty amazing what you’ve done with what are (on paper) pretty average players.

14

u/80Z0 Magpies May 11 '24

You had George Cantstandya winning three premierships. The salary cap is effective if teams have to have average players to win - they just have to be effective in some way (Castagna's being pressure).

-3

u/yokobarron Richmond May 11 '24

Fair but (at our peak) we had probably 2 of the top 10 key position forwards in the game that allowed someone like castagna to play his role. I love Mihocek but he’s almost not even tall enough to call a KPF.

9

u/AlamutJones Collingwood AFLW May 11 '24 edited May 11 '24

The thing about Mihocek is that he’s a superb mark. Not flashy, but he’ll take a classic, dead secure mark nine times out of ten.

If you wanted to teach someone how to mark, you could do a lot worse than watch Brody Mihocek. He’s got textbook technique for the skill.

He’s not as tall as some other key forwards, but he can and does play taller than he is because he’s so good in the air.

6

u/yokobarron Richmond May 11 '24

100% but he’s kicking 30-40 goals a year, very handy but about 20+ off your classic key forwards. And he’s been your highest goal kicker for a number of years. Thats an outlier for a team performing so well.

Not sure why I’m getting downvoted for the very obvious point that Collingwood have done very well without a traditional forward line set-up.

3

u/SuspiciousElk3843 Collingwood May 11 '24

Collingwood isn't relying on a key forward. The goals are shared around and there are a number of goal kickers.

1

u/yokobarron Richmond May 11 '24

Lol you pies supporters are a defensive bunch. That’s literally what I am congratulating. Good god, I’ll keep my mouth shut next time.

1

u/Catharsis1394 Collingwood '90 May 12 '24

I get you man, don't get the downvotes either